• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Modest Man

  • .
  • Topics
    • Fashion
    • Shoes
    • Accessories
    • EDC
    • Hairstyles
    • Cologne
    • See All
  • Reviews
  • Outfit Ideas
  • About
    • Start Here
    • Contact
Home / Blog / Product Reviews

Goodlife Review: Ethical but the Fit Isn’t for Everyone

Published on July 11, 2022 by Ryan Hallstrom · Product Reviews May contain affiliate links (what's this?)

In this hands-on review, we share our thoughts on the clothing brand Goodlife. Read on to learn more about the company and their products.

Table of Contents

  • Quick Take
  • About Goodlife
  • My Build
  • The Products I Tried
  • Tri-Blend Scallop Crew
  • Double Dye Linen Shirt Jacket
  • StretchTex Volley Short
  • Essential Twill Pant
  • What I Like
  • What I Didn’t Like
  • My Recommendation
Goodlife Review
Check current price

Goodlife is an ethical brand that makes clothing basics for men and women. I tried some of their items to test the fit and quality. Here’s my review of what I tried.

Quick Take

Don’t have time to read the full review? No worries! Here’s a quick summary:

Pros

  • The StretchTex Volley Shorts are pretty much perfect
  • The Essential Twill Pants are like a high-quality, casual chino
  • Goodlife is a very ethical brand

Cons

  • The Tri-Blend Scallop Crew is so thin that I question how well it’ll hold up
  • The Double Dye Linen Shirt Jacket has a very slim fit and doesn’t have many jacket qualities
  • It would be great to have length options for the Essential Twill Pants

Click here to check out Goodlife, or read on for the full review.

About Goodlife

Goodlife is a pretty new brand started by Chris Molnar in New York City in 2013.

While the site doesn’t share much about the man behind the brand, it does share really important details about Goodlife’s mission.

Goodlife outfit with Blundstones

It’s very clear that they’re an ethical company. In fact, they “promise to manufacture products responsibly.”

Goodlife also has their Goodlife Loop recycling program, which allows customers to send in any Goodlife products that they’re no longer wearing.

By partnering with Green Tree Textiles, Goodlife is able to ensure that the clothing is shredded so it can be used as insulation for housing.

Goodlife products provide a fresh but nostalgic twist on some of style’s greatest hits.

from Goodlife’s about page

Obviously, no brand is all about sustainability. The look and feel of the products matter too. Goodlife aims to “provide high-quality classics, reimagined for modern living” that always have “versatility and comfort at the core.”

Needless to say, they keep both style and ethics in mind.

My Build

For reference, I’m 6’1″ and 170lbs. I have a 37″ chest and usually wear Large tops. My ideal pants size is 32×32.

The Products I Tried

I tried four of Goodlife’s products:

  • Tri-Blend Scallop Crew
  • Double Dye Linen Shirt Jacket
  • StretchTex Volley Short
  • Essential Twill Pant

Here’s a breakdown of my thoughts on each of them…

Tri-Blend Scallop Crew

The Tri-Blend Scallop Crew is made of a very soft polyester, cotton, and rayon blend.

It’s a comfortable shirt that has a good stretch to it, but it’s very thin. Personally, I usually prefer shirts that are medium or heavy-weight. While I know that a lot of guys prefer thin t-shirts, the Tri-Blend Scallop Crew is concerningly thin to me.

Goodlife scalloped shirt and Seiko SKX013
Check current price

I didn’t find any problems with the quality of it while I was wearing it, but I question how it would hold up over time.

On that note, they have a t-shirt subscription service where you receive new shirts from them every one, two, three, or six months. Goodlife calls this service the T-Shirt Club.

Maybe it’s a good option if you’re very sold on their shirts, but I find this sales model questionable. If you’re spending around $50 on a t-shirt, it should be high enough quality to last several years and be able to take a beating.

I refresh my t-shirts every couple of years or so and donate the old ones to a thrift shop, but it seems excessive to be needing new shirts every six months (or less).

Another note about the Tri-Blend Scallop Crew is that it does, of course, have a scalloped hem. Overall, I don’t understand the purpose of a scalloped hem other than it giving you more shirt to tuck in. Untucked, it feels too long and has a baggier look to it. It doesn’t suit my style.

Luckily, Goodlife makes shirts with regular hems too. Choose wisely if you’re going to buy any of their t-shirts. Try sizing down if you are going with a scalloped hem and want a less baggy look.

Double Dye Linen Shirt Jacket

I’ve owned a few great shirt jackets in my day, but the Double Dye Linen Shirt Jacket isn’t one of them.

Shirt jackets that I’ve tried are usually a thick material that makes you question “Is it a shirt or a jacket?” Well, it’s both. That’s why it’s called a shirt jacket of course!

If you do a quick image search for “shirt jacket”, you’ll see what I mean. Shackets, as they’re often called, are thicker than a shirt but not as thick and heavy as a jacket.

Goodlife’s “shirt jacket” feels like a thin shirt that they added a couple of extra pockets to.

Goodlife shirt jacket and scalloped shirt
Check current price

I know it’s made of linen, so I don’t expect it to be very thick, but I think they’re using the term “shirt jacket” loosely.

Even guys who prefer a slim fit might find the Double Dye Linen Shirt Jacket to be a bit odd. The fit is very slender and really tapers in at the sides. It feels like a woman’s garment to me (so much so that I actually gave it to my sister after I tried it out).

Due to the very slim fit, I recommend sizing up if you’re interested in buying one.

StretchTex Volley Short

Goodlife totally nailed it with the StretchTex Volley Short. They’re a pair of swim shorts made mostly of polyester and some stretchy material.

They have a 5.5″ inseam, which is a great length for most guys, especially for a swim short. (Yes, you can pull of short shorts).

I’ve been wearing them to the beach a lot, and I have no complaints. They feel good, they’re high-quality, and the silicone-tipped drawcords are a subtle but awesome touch.

Essential Twill Pant

The fourth product I tried from Goodlife’s collection is their Essential Twill Pant. They’re basically chinos with an elastic waistband, but they look a little more casual than your standard pair of chinos.

They’re super comfortable and have some nice color options. I got the navy which looks good, although they do kind of look like scrubs (as my girlfriend pointed out).

Goodlife pants with blundstones
Check current price

One complaint is that you can’t choose a precise length for the inseam. They offer different sizes (small, medium, large, etc.), but I’d love to be able to choose the length.

I have a 32″ waist so I went with the medium size. They’re shorter than the pants that I normally wear, but they still look good, especially for spring and summer wear.

What I Like

Goodlife pretty much nailed it with the bottoms. They’re high quality, comfortable, and they look good. The StretchTex Volley Shorts are now my go-to swimming trunks, and the Essential Twill Pants have quickly become a wardrobe staple for me.

What I Didn’t Like

The tops I tried from Goodlife missed the mark for me.

The Tri-Blend Scallop Crew is very thin, and I have some concerns about how well it’ll hold up. Especially considering that they offer a t-shirt subscription service.

I love shirt jackets, but the Double Dye Linen Shirt Jacket feels a lot like a shirt and not at all like a jacket apart from two extra pockets they added. The slim and tapered fit may be great for some guys, but I’d prefer a more standard fit.

My Recommendation

Overall, I found Goodlife’s bottoms to be worthy of keeping, and they’ve gotten a lot of wear so far.

The tops weren’t my style, but if you don’t mind the cons that I mentioned, try them out!

One thing that Goodlife certainly does right is their ethical practices. Whether you like their clothing or not, their brand philosophy is something that anyone can respect.

Leave a comment below if you’ve tried any of Goodlife’s products. I’d love to hear what you think about them!

Product Reviews ethical clothing, Goodlife

Related Posts

Pact Review
Pact Review: Sustainable and Stylish Wardrobe Staples
Tentree Review
Tentree Review: Comfortable Clothing From a Sustainable Brand
Thursday Boots Bifold Wallet Review
Thursday Boots Bifold Wallet Review: The Upgrade Your EDC Needs
Thursday Boots Legend Chelsea Boots Review
Thursday Boots Legend Chelsea Boots Review: Your New Go-To

About Ryan Hallstrom

TMM's Senior Editor, Ryan Hallstrom is from Horseheads, NY, the only town in America named in honor of military packhorses. When he’s not writing about menswear, Ryan enjoys reading, whittling, running, and perfecting his penmanship.

Background: In 2021, Ryan graduated from Brigham Young University where he majored in American Studies and Russian. Before completing his schooling, he had a wide range of job titles including finish carpenter, usher, elevator operator (yes, that’s a real job), landscaper, tour guide, and more.

In January 2022, Ryan began working full-time as The Modest Man’s Senior Editor. In this role, he not only edits all articles prior to publication but also is a frequent contributor to the blog. He enjoys crafting in-depth product reviews (often testing items in extreme environments), helpful self-improvement articles, and detailed clothing guides.

His interest in men’s style stems from the examples of men in his family:

“Growing up, a lot of the men I looked up to dressed well. My dad is always clean-shaven and makes sure that he looks presentable before heading out the door, and my grandfather, who owned and operated a dairy farm, usually wore work pants with a sharp crease and a button-up work shirt.”

However, it wasn’t until the end of high school that Ryan began to care about how he looked. Gradually, over the next few years, he started to dress better and learn about style. “Finding clothes that fit helped me to become more confident. I find that when I try to dress well, I feel better.”

Expertise: Ryan has loved writing since an early age, and in college began contributing to and editing for university publications. After college, he began freelance writing and editing. He’s written from blogs and magazines such as Real Men Real Style, Life in the Finger Lakes, and Gentleman Within.

An avid traveler who spends plenty of time outdoors, Ryan appreciates clothes, footwear and accessories that can take a beating. His reviews often include long-term, thorough testing in extreme weather conditions.

Ryan has also spent more time in a suit and tie than most guys, so he's well qualified to write about classic menswear, business casual and formalwear.

More Articles by This Author

Facebook LinkedIn

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download). No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Reader Interactions

Ask Me Anything Cancel reply

Got questions? Want to share your opinion? Comment below!

Primary Sidebar

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download).

No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Trending Articles

Men over 40 style

How to Dress Well In Your 40s and 50s (and Beyond)

Fashion brands for short men

Where to Buy Clothes for Short Men (2022 Guide)

Seiko 5 SNK805

31 Great Watches For Small Wrists (Updated for 2023)

Best Business Casual Shoes for Men

Top 8 Best Business Casual Shoes for Men (2023 Guide)

Business casual outfits

The Complete Guide to Business Casual Style for Men

Topics

  • Clothing & Style
  • Outfit Ideas
  • Fitness
  • Product Reviews
  • Dating & Confidence
  • Grooming
  • Men of Modest Height
  • Income Reports

Footer

The Modest Man logo

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Home • Blog • Resources • Contact • Advertise

 

Privacy Policy & Affiliate Disclosure • Terms & Conditions

 

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

 

Copyright © 2023 The Modest Man (Registered Trademark)