• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Modest Man

  • .
  • Start Here
  • Blog
  • About
  • Outfit Ideas
  • Free Stuff
Home / Blog / Product Reviews

New Republic Review: Affordable, Quality Sneakers and Boots

Published on November 10, 2021 by Karlton Miko Tyack · Boots, Product Reviews, Sneakers May contain affiliate links (what's this?)

In this hands-on review of New Republic, I try on some of their footwear items and assess each pair’s fit, feel and style.

Table of Contents

  • Quick Take
  • New Republic: The Brand
  • What I Tried
  • Bowery Canvas Sneaker
  • Kurt Leather Sneakers
  • Stanton Recycled Suede Slip-On Sneakers
  • Sonoma Suede Chelsea Boots
  • Final Thoughts on New Republic
New Republic brand review

As a fan of basics and classic silhouettes, New Republic has been on my radar since internet fashionistas dubbed their Kurts the affordable answer to Common Projects. Add GQ constantly plugging their Sonoma Chelseas on top of that, and I simply had to dive in.

After wearing four pairs of their shoes in different situations, I’ve appraised who this brand is and isn’t for.

Quick Take

Short on time? Here are my thoughts on the brand:

New Republic offers basic and essential shoes at accessible prices for most, if not all, guys. Their sneakers, slip-ons, and boots feature leather, suede, and canvas constructions, and come in neutral colors like white, black, slate, taupe, and navy. 

New Republic Kurt Leather Sneakers with cuffed pants
New Republic Kurt Leather Sneakers

They avoid expenditures anywhere that it’s absolutely unnecessary, while also averting consequential shortcuts. For example, they use Chinese manufacturing, but use good materials, like the sustainably-sourced Italian leather on their Kurts. For a basics company, that’s fine with me.

New Republic uses traditional templates, but puts their own twist on details without compromising each shoe’s versatility. They have a wide range of sizes, and everything I tried was exceedingly comfortable.

Bottom Line: New Republic offers a compelling value proposition. Because of the low prices, non-boring neutrality, and versatility, I can see a guy using New Republic for most of his shoe closet, sprinkled in with some hardcore investments.

They’re also a great brand for any guy looking to do a full shoe closet overhaul.

New Republic: The Brand

For 30 years, fashion designer Mark McNairy has collaborated with brands like Timberland and adidas, celebs and tastemakers like Pharrell, and was the creative director of Ivy League favorite, J.Press. Despite this elite multi-decade career, he started New Republic in 2016, with all people in mind.

New Republic Bowery Canvas Sneakers
New Republic Bowery Canvas Sneakers

The LA-based digital native offers footwear and accessories at a high quality-to-price ratio.

Their core line is a collection of sleek basics like sneakers and loafers, in different materials, and in a variety of colors. New Republic shoes are made in China, but everything is handcrafted and last-constructed.

What I Tried

I tried the Bowery Canvas Sneaker, Kurt Leather Sneaker, Stanton Recycled Suede Sneaker and Sonoma Suede Chelsea Boot. Read on to see what I think about each of them.

Bowery Canvas Sneaker

Because of its comfort, convenience, and versatile look, the Bowery Canvas Sneaker has become my go-to weekend and after-work shoe.

Design

The silhouette takes low-profile to a new level. The profile line from the lip to the outsole is as flat as it can get without folding into a full 180 degrees.

From there, the sole is a little over an inch tall. This flush look isn’t disrupted when you slip your feet in either, since your feet will sink into the cork insole a bit.

New Republic Bowery Canvas Sneakers close up
New Republic Bowery Canvas Sneakers

I’m a big fan of this super-flat extra-minimal minimalism, especially in the navy color I got them in, because it’s really as versatile as a sneaker can get. You can wear these guys at the airport, on the boardwalk, at a cocktail, and on casual Fridays.

I wore them with khakis and a blazer to a boat party and got photographed a lot, so they must’ve looked good.

I also think the added dimension of the high soles prevents that clown effect that flat shoes sometimes give.

New Republic Bowery Canvas Sneakers back

As someone with thin calves, I’m always on the lookout for this.

Comfort and Fit

These fit true to size and the cork insoles are buoyant and immediately comfortable. The only “break-in” pain I experienced was that my pinky toes rubbed on the interior a bit, probably because of how flat it is.

New Republic Bowery Canvas Sneakers side view
New Republic Bowery Canvas Sneakers

This also snuck up on me during my third or fourth outing with these shoes. I just put some plasters on my pinky toes during this period, which only lasted a little over a week.

Price

They’re listed on the website as being $79, which is an excellent price for value. Moreover, they’re often marked down to $39, which is even more affordable than canvas sneakers from mid-tier brands like Banana Republic. A+ on price.

Pros and Cons

Here are the Pros and Cons of the Bowery Canvas Sneaker:

Pros

The Bowerys are overall effective basics, with slightly sleeker profiles than the average canvas sneaker. They’re versatile, immediately comfortable, an easy shoe to slip in and out of, and offer topnotch value.

Cons

Genuinely, the only con was the rubbing on my pinky toe. This didn’t last long and was easily dealt with. I wish they weren’t made in China, but since all of New Republic’s shoes are, I’ll mention it here once, as a con that applies to each pair I review, and we’ll call it a day.

Kurt Leather Sneakers

Commonly referred to as the best sub-100 alternative to the Common Projects Achilles, the Kurts are a bang-for-buck white sneaker.

The Design

One of the reasons I’m lenient about the Chinese manufacturing situation with New Republic is that they work smart within their budget. The material is sustainably-sourced Italian leather, way nicer than the kind you get in the adidas Stan Smiths. They’re also shockingly durable.

New Republic Kurt Leather Sneakers side
New Republic Kurt Leather Sneakers

The Kurts sport the classic low-profile white sneaker silhouette. Not to belabor the Common Projects comparison, but the toe is ever slightly more rounded than the toe on the Achilles.

The Kurts aren’t an exceptionally wide shoe, so I actually prefer this added mass. It doesn’t look like the upper just sinks into the sole. It also separates it from the Bowerys more, shape-wise.

New Republic Kurt Leather Sneakers back

They feature the New Republic trademark hand-sewn signature stitch on the heel tab. I appreciate this minimal labeling, and the cool-factor of the “vague branding ” approach.

Price

No complaints here. For under $100 you get a classic white sneaker made from sustainably-sourced Italian leather. 

You could pay a little more for say Thursday’s Premiers, but honestly, if a casual white shoe is that much more important to you, I’d recommend saving up even more for the Koio Capris at $300.

Fit and Comfort

Comfort is one of the Kurt’s biggest strengths. It has a molded EVA foam with tencel, which is like memory foam, adding airflow to your step. Suffice to say, I didn’t experience any break-in period. 

New Republic Kurt Leather Sneakers front
New Republic Kurt Leather Sneakers

Bonus points for the wide range of sizes offered. You can get them as small as size 4, as big as size 15, and all of the half sizes. 

Pros and Cons

Here are the Pros and Cons of the Kurt Leather Sneaker:

Pros

The Kurts are truly the best value-for-money, under $100 shoe, when it comes to the Achilles-esque school of design. They’re super comfortable, versatile, and surprisingly durable. You can wear these for a while before seeing any noticeable wear.

Cons

They‘re definitely one of New Republic’s popular models. That being the case, keep in mind that they’re a small-batch manufacturing company, so production quantities are small. Not every color and size is always available.

Stanton Recycled Suede Slip-On Sneakers

The Stantons are a really well-designed sneaker that’s far more interesting than any other slip-ons I’ve seen in this price-range.  

The Design

Despite how little is going on here, I actually find the Stantons to be the most impressive in the design category. Like how they approach their budget, New Republic does so much with so little, creating a classic silhouette with cool details.

New Republic Stanton Suede Slip Ons
New Republic Stanton Suede Slip Ons

The upper is made out of just two parts, not including the elastic.

Between the swerve action where the front piece meets the back piece, and the back’s slightly different tone, there’s visual intrigue in this simple shoe.

The front is recycled suede and the back is canvas, a slightly lighter tone. 

New Republic Stanton Suede Slip Ons back

The front of the outsole has an interesting series of texturing in the style of metal tread plates, so it’s sort of like the shoe’s grill. The rest of the sole sports an accent line in the same color as the upper.

The logo is big and bold on the back heel in embossed rubber, while the hand-stitched signature is on the back tab, just like the Kurts.

Fit and Comfort

These definitely fit true to size, and are the most comfortable model in this group. It’s cozy where it needs to be (cork insole, padded collar), and breathable where it needs to be (lightweight upper).

New Republic Stanton Suede Slip Ons side view

Despite its flat silhouette, it didn’t rub my pinky toes like the Bowerys did, since the interior is just one piece of material with no lacing system.

Price

Great value is definitely a theme with New Republic. At the time of this writing, the Stantons are priced at $78, marked down to $46.80. You’d have to turn to fast-fashion for a cheaper slip-on, and they wouldn’t be as interesting.

Pros and Cons

Here are the Pros and Cons of the Stanton Recycled Suede Slip-Ons:

Pros

The Stantons are an excellently designed slip-on shoe that uses details and textures to make a minimal slip-on look pretty cool. I’d say these are almost universally attractive. I can see on-the-fence guys thinking, “for under $50, why not?”

Cons

Unlike a sneaker with lacing, there’s literally nothing going on on the upper except for the excellent suede texture. There’s nothing to camouflage creases and scuffs.

New Republic Stanton Suede Slip Ons close up
New Republic Stanton Suede Slip Ons

I’ve worn these for about a month now and they’re looking just fine so this isn’t a huge concern so far. I just want to note that this clean, minimalist shoe isn’t the kind that can pull off the worn look.

I don’t love the huge embossed branding on the back heel. I get that you have to put it somewhere, but that super cool hand-sewn stitching on the heel tab is enough, in my opinion.

Sonoma Suede Chelsea Boots

The Sonoma Suede Chelseas are getting a lot of attention for being the best affordable Chelsea boot on the market. 

The Design

The Sonomas are sleek, but take a moderate approach to each design component, making them easy to like.

For example, the neck is slender but not too long (six inches high from the bottom of the outsole), and the toe tapers thinly, but doesn’t get too sharp.

New Republic Sonoma Chelsea Boots inner side
New Republic Sonoma Chelsea Boots

These shoes also sport that desert boot remix look, with its crepe sole and suede upper.

They’re built with a flat welt resulting in a pretty tight construction. The Sonomas are an overall solid shoe, design wise.

Fit and Comfort

These run just a tad small, though not distractingly so. I got my Sonomas at my true number size, 8, and I wish I had just a little bit more room in the toe.

The leather insole isn’t as comfortable as the cork of the Bowerys and EVAs of the Kurts, but that’s apples and oranges. 

New Republic Sonoma Chelsea Boots back

Besides, I do like the structure that the leather insole provides. It makes me want to stand straighter and taller.

Price

At the time of this writing, the Sonomas are priced at $128, marked down to $89.60. 

New Republic Sonoma Chelsea Boots pull tabs

Broken record much? New Republic has excellent prices.

Moreover, crepe sole is a cool style, but the truth is, it doesn’t last. It’s not reparable and it’s not replaceable. I personally don’t think there’s any reason to spend a lot of money on crepe, so New Republic really nailed that category here.

Pros and Cons

Here are the Pros and Cons of the Sonoma Suede Chelseas:

Pros

The Sonomas are a simple and classic style, with a chic silhouette. The crepe sole and suede upper combination gives them an effortlessly masculine vibe, at an excellent price.

Cons

Crepe sole gets pretty filthy and sticky. I love the look, but they’re so porous, that if you were to step into some gum, you’d be living with it for a while.

New Republic Sonoma Chelsea Boots walking
New Republic Sonoma Chelsea Boots

I also noticed that for the larger set (size 12 and up), there aren’t half sizes, and these do run slightly small. This doesn’t affect me, but bigger gents take notice.

Final Thoughts on New Republic

Overall, New Republic serves up classics with distinct detailing, and refreshing price points. The main inconvenience is that you can’t shop for them in person.

This is normal to digital native direct-to-consumer brands though. And honestly, for as low as the prices are, I’m okay with trying things on, then returning them if they’re the wrong size. You just pay with time, instead of money.

And again, everything is made in China, but they aren’t out there building these elaborately complicated boots.

I think it’s commendable that New Republic spends money only where they need to for the purpose of democratizing fashion vs doing so to gain room to overcharge.

The online community treats New Republic like the affordable answer to Common Projects, but I’m seeing more and more people rocking the brand for what it is.

It’s sort of like how the Seiko SKX started as a Sub alternative before becoming its own (different kind) of icon.

Boots, Product Reviews, Sneakers canvas sneakers, Leather sneakers, Men's Boots, New Republic

Related Posts

Cariuma Leather Salvas Sneakers Review
Cariuma Leather Salvas Sneakers Review
Thursday Boot Captain Review
Thursday Boots Captain Review: Worth It In 2022?
Types of Sneakers for Guys
30 Types of Sneaker Styles Guys Should Wear in 2023
Thursday Premier High Top Sneaker Review
Thursday Premier High Top Sneaker Review 

About Karlton Miko Tyack

Karlton Miko Tyack is a freelance writer covering watches, gear, and style. He was born in LA, studied art history in Boston, and is a lover of rugby, football, and optimism.

Background: Karlton studied art in Boston while working in local galleries. This led to a career in corporate art consulting, hunting down the perfect pieces for specific brand or business.

Transitioning into freelance writing, he moved back to his hometown of Los Angeles, where he managed top accounts with art publisher TASCHEN. His clientele included prominent names in fashion, luxury, and sports.

He then moved to NYC to work as a client liaison at Sotheby’s auction house in New York, where he worked with collectors of fine art, as well as watches, wine, and whiskey.

A lifelong watch enthusiast, Karlton has worked with quality timepieces of all price points and calibers, vintage and contemporary. Tyack’s watch obsession began when he received an Omega Seamaster for his 15th birthday.

Expertise: Through his work in fine art and with Sotheby's auction house, Karlton has developed a deep knowledge of timepieces, whiskey and menswear. He's written for publishers like LA Weekly and Harvard. Here at TMM, Karlton covers watches and men's fashion.

More Articles by This Author

Facebook Instagram LinkedIn

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download). No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Reader Interactions

Ask Me Anything Cancel reply

Got questions? Want to share your opinion? Comment below!

Primary Sidebar

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download).

No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Top 5 Favorites for Fall & Winter 2022

  1. Thursday Boots Captain – still the best Goodyear-welted boot under $200 (full review here) 🥾
  2. Matte for Men SPF Lotion – because you should be using moisturizer with SPF
  3. Darn Tough Wool Socks – possibly the best boot socks you can buy 🧦
  4. Hamilton Khaki Mechanical – perfect everyday mechanical watch under $500 (Amazon/Jomashop)
  5. Flint & Tinder Waxed Jacket – great fit, perfect weight for fall 👍🏼

Trending Articles

Men over 40 style

How to Dress Well In Your 40s and 50s (and Beyond)

Fashion brands for short men

Where to Buy Clothes for Short Men (2022 Guide)

Seiko 5 SNK805

31 Great Watches For Small Wrists (Updated for 2023)

Best Business Casual Shoes for Men

Top 8 Best Business Casual Shoes for Men (2023 Guide)

Business casual outfits

The Complete Guide to Business Casual Style for Men

Topics

  • Clothing & Style
  • Outfit Ideas
  • Fitness
  • Product Reviews
  • Dating & Confidence
  • Grooming
  • Men of Modest Height
  • Income Reports

Footer

The Modest Man logo

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Home • Blog • Resources • Contact • Advertise

 

Privacy Policy & Affiliate Disclosure • Terms & Conditions

 

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

 

Copyright © 2023 The Modest Man (Registered Trademark)