• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Modest Man

  • .
  • Start Here
  • Blog
  • About
  • Outfit Ideas
  • Free Stuff
Home / Blog / Clothing and Style

Big Apple Style: 12 Best Menswear Stores in NYC

Published on May 19, 2021 by Karlton Miko Tyack · Clothing and Style May contain affiliate links (what's this?)

If you’re a New Yorker looking for some cool places to buy clothes, we’ve got you covered. Read on to see the best menswear stores in NYC.

Table of Contents

  • Best Menswear Stores in Brooklyn
  • Best Menswear Stores in Manhattan
  • New York Men’s Clothing Stores, Multiple Locations
  • Conclusion
Best Menswear Stores in New York City Products Collage Hero Image

Even for men who’ve lived in New York for years, clothes shopping in the world’s fashion capital can be overwhelming. With countless lifestyle-focused boutiques, targeting your specific sartorial needs is often a matter of figuring out what store you should go to. 

Ask yourself, what exact piece or pieces am I looking for? Is it for work? What’s my budget? If you’re looking to change up your style, sometimes all you need to do is shop in a different neighborhood or borough than you usually do.

Our list of the 12 best menswear stores in New York City includes shops in Brooklyn, Manhattan, and those with multiple locations within the city.

Best Menswear Stores in Brooklyn

If you’re looking for some cool shops in Brooklyn, check these out…

10 ft. Single by Stella Dallas

Appropriately located in Williamsburg, 10 ft. Single boasts a generous helping of vintage, Americana, and workwear. The entrance gallery is stacked with accessories in glass cases and barrels of scarves.

Here, you’ll find a mix of one-of-a-kinds and nostalgic quintessentials. Further in, the exposed brick interior is decked with concert tees from every era, including Led Zeppelin circa 1975 and AC/DC.

10 ft. Single by Stella Dallas
Source: @10ftsinglebystelladallas

If you’re into the utility-chic look, 10 ft. Single is filled to the brim with authentic military jackets. If you’re a treasure hunter, the shop’s modest size and saturated yet well-curated shelves make for an easy perusing experience, compared to bigger vintage stores.

They offer a large selection of 60s, 70s, and 80s printed button-downs, flannels, corduroy pants, jeans, and well-structured outerwear.

Some pieces that caught my eye include a Dick Tracey-style trench coat and some vintage Nordic sweaters. The back room is where the rarer pieces are kept, including sportswear from as far back as the 1920s. 

Alter Brooklyn

Greenpoint’s answer to runway-focused SoHo shops, Alter carries several indie fashion brands. They hone in on pieces with the cooler, more down-to-earth slant popularized by Brooklynites. 

Well to-do Prospect Heights citizens reputably love inexpensive-looking styles that are secretly premium-built, with a price to match. At Alter, however, you’ll find well-tailored hipster-chic offerings at reasonable prices.

Alter Brooklyn BANKS VOID SHIRT
Check current price

For example, they sell stylish separates from acclaimed fashion designer Banks, all for under $100. Some pieces include the Plain Downtown pant with a trendy high-hem and their hip leopard-print and vintage-washed button-ups.

Other brands carried by this neighborhood favorite include Kardo, Fried Rice and Native Youth. Their collections are updated regularly, with an eye for very local or very international designers.

Brooklyn Circus 

Brooklyn Circus was founded by graphic designer and local celebrity, Ouigi “The Bearded Man” Theodore. With his magazine-style editing, the vintage streetwear offered at the store is timelessly hip.

The in-house brand items are renowned in the fashion world and include bomber jackets, scarves, fitted basics, and hats. Brooklyn Circus is the place to go if you’re looking to change up your silhouette with some iconic layers.

They carry other cool designers like Todd Snyder,  Mark McNairy, Cheap Monday, and Wolverine, with a focus on heavy, dark denim, military casuals, and artistically-designed t-shirts.

Brooklyn Circus TS x Champion BKc Boxing Sweatshirt
Check current price

They’ve even won a Shorty Award for shaking up the small business space and for their hip internet presence.

The store’s interior design is a mix of vintage and urban elegance, featuring antiques on dark-wood floors below, and a chic black chandelier above.

Just like its clothes, the spot boasts an effortlessly cool style with its roots in fashion history.

Best Menswear Stores in Manhattan

If you want some solid places to buy clothes in Manhattan, here are our recommendations…

Saturdays NYC

Saturdays casualwear combines the bright colors and relaxed fits of surfer culture with a distinctly New York sophistication. Their lounge shirts are some of their best pieces.

The Canty Peace Poplin, for example, features a fun but muted check pattern and a nostalgic camp-collar. Most of their shirts can be worn on the beach or as a loose outer layer in place of an open utility shirt.

Saturdays New York City Geller Quilted Jacket
Check current price

Other cool pieces include cotton jersey hoodies and shorts, embroidered long-sleeved shirts, and, of course, board shorts. The Timothy Rose mid-length swim shorts, for example, feature a mod pixelated rose pattern on it. Saturdays NYC generally doesn’t shy away from fun, eye-catching patterns. 

Experience-wise, their roomy and airy space is an oasis from the bustle of SoHo with a coffee bar and surfboard rental. If you’re looking for stylish, comfortable staples and on-trend basics, Saturdays NYC has you covered.

Blue in Green

Blue in Green, or BiG to locals, is the place to go if you want to level up your denim game. The jeans in this modest boutique come in nuanced international fits that are hard to come by in the States. You can also have your jeans custom-made.

BiG is the leading Japanese denim shop in the city. We’re talking premium raw selvedge denim, woven on shuttle looms and dyed with natural vibrant colors.

Blue in Green BiG Artic Down Parka Black
Check current price

Some brands include TCB, Oni, Kapital, and Pure Blue Japan. The clean lines and tapered fit of the XX-013-BB Pure Blue jeans is so versatile, even those who don’t typically wear jeans could easily incorporate it into their pants rotation.

They also carry other handmade shoes, uniquely-patterned scarves, and Americana style tops. Their non-denim offerings are curated from small-production brands, international labels, and rarer pieces from bigger brands.

Even if you’re just here for the basics, you may unintentionally walk out more fashion-forward than when you walked in. 

C’H’C’M’

Since 2008, C’H’C’M’ (which stands for Clinton Hill Classic Menswear) has provided the denizens of New York with classic formal pieces, and stylishly minimalist casual clothes. It has a loyal base of patrons who enjoy its esteemed but understated reputation, never allowing itself to get tragically hip.

The shop boasts a tightly-curated selection of European, American, and Japanese designers including Evan Kinori, Barena, Niuhans, and Nanamica.

C’H’C’M’ carries several classic blazers, all with modern but trend-resistant fits. If you want a single-pleat cotton pant, their Kinori Sumi Ink trouser is a fashionable option that will last forever.

CHCM Two Button Blazer
Check current price

C’H’C’M’ also sells its own minimalist clothing line, having developed special limited projects with designers from around the world. All of these pieces are developed in the UK, Italy, Japan, France, and the USA, fully avoiding fast-fashion shortcuts.

If you like simple but chic clothes, and are allergic to the long lines of “cool” shops, Clinton Hill provides a peaceful and civilized shopping experience.

Fine and Dandy

Fine and Dandy focuses on gentleman style and isn’t afraid to have fun with formal and classic attire. When it comes to basic pieces, they offer high-quality and personalized shirts in every style and fit.

However, Fine and Dandy also sells a comprehensive selection of outerwear and accessories, if you’re looking for a few classy pieces without necessarily going full dapper.

Opened in 2008 to instant acclaim, their USA-made offerings include bow ties, handkerchiefs, hats, tie bars, lapel pins, cummerbunds, and even dog collars and leashes. They often have Ivy-approved blazers and pea coats in classic fits. 

Fine and Dandy Ties
Check current price

Fine and Dandy’s custom shirt program is a Manhattan go-to. It boasts over 300 rotating fabrics, 16 collar options, 12 cuff options, and plenty other customizations on top of that.

If Boutique

There are few Manhattan stores as quintessentially downtown as SoHo’s If Boutique. It’s been providing the city’s glitterati with unique fashions since 1978, long before SoHo was a cultural epicenter -and long before you could walk a block there without getting mugged. 

They were selling Marc Jacobs and John Paul Gaultier to artists, musicians, aristocrats, and Wall Streeters before department stores were privy.

That tradition carries on today, with If carrying the latest fashions from New York, Japanese, and European brands like Dries Van Noten, Veronique Branquinho, and Junya Wantanabe.

If Boutique TAKAHIROMIYASHITA TheSoloist Crew Neck Fair Isle Sweater
Check current price

Sure, not everyone is comfortable wearing the loud patterns and fashion-forward fit of their Uma Wang Giovanni coat. However, their Dawson coat, which has an edgy asymmetrical buttoning when worn closed, wears just like a slightly cooler charcoal tweed when it’s unbuttoned.

This creatively edited shop is worth a visit for practical shoppers, as well as the artistically and historically curious.

Freemans Sporting Club 

Freemans Sporting Club is a posh nook where you can get a unique made-to-fit custom suit. Bespoke services are their specialty, so it’s an effective resource for a big formal event or an important business trip.

The good news is, despite its upscale status, the specialists who work there treat you like you’re at your local Cheers bar.

Freemans Sporting Club FSC Chino Navy
Check current price

They also sell cool casual shirts, shoes, and plenty of classically masculine accessories. These include full-grain leather gloves, belts, and even flashlights and tool kits. Bonus points that everything is made and sourced locally. 

Overall, Freemans Sporting Club is an elegant fashion boutique that’s gearhead and bloke-friendly. If you’re looking for a classy, but functional suit that will last a lifetime, this Lower East Side gem is one of the best in the game. 

New York Men’s Clothing Stores, Multiple Locations

Luckily, there are some great stores with multiple locations…

Kith

This streetwear trove is undeniably aimed at hypebeasts and sneakerheads. However, Kith is an excellent source of premium athletic wear and weekend attire for anyone looking to elevate their gym lockers and casual drawers. 

Their in-house 2021 custom collection consists of polos, active shorts, sweatpants, and more. They’re made in custom fabrics and prints, including unique shades of deep purple and green, and a prevalent illustrative flower pattern.

Kith Stone Island Membrana 3L TC Hooded Jacket
Check current price

One standout piece is the satin exterior Gorman jacket, fully branded with the KITH logo.

KITH was founded in 2011 by New York-native and shoe industry legend, Ronnie Fieg, who is also known for his work with brands like ASICS, adidas, and Polo Ralph Lauren.

Naturally, KITH sells the latest fashion-forward trainers from heritage brands and hip contemporary brands. These include Nike, Off-White, Bleecker, New Balance, Gel Lyte, ASICs, John Elliot, and several others.

KITH is also New York’s premier shop for limited edition shoes. They have locations in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and in Manhasset, smack-dab in between the city and the Hamptons.

Bonobos

This upscale subsidiary of Walmart is for the guy that doesn’t like shopping or going to the tailor. Launched as an ecommerce fashion brand in 2007, Bonobos now has several locations throughout New York City. They’re the largest clothing brand in the US that was built on the internet.

Bonobos specializes in pants. They’re famous for their signature curved waistband, which they apply to all of their trousers from jeans to dress pants to chinos, allowing them to conform to all body types.

Bonobos Classic Pique Polo
Check current price

Out of all the shops for smart casual attire, Bonobos has the most efficient ratio of low-maintenance to well-fitted. You can even get Italian wool tuxedos here for less than a grand, and on reasonably-termed payment plans.

Their charming Cobble Hill shop in Brooklyn has the bespoke service of a Savile Row tailor, and their 5th Avenue Flagship has the high-end experience of a decades-old fashion brand without the pretension.

Atelier

Atelier treats and displays their clothes like pieces in an art gallery. Their avant-garde showrooms sell separates from recognizable high-fashion brands and cool, esoteric designers fresh from Fashion Week. They have a location in Flushing and a men’s store in Manhattan.

Even if you aren’t a hardcore fashionista, Atelier sells elevated basics and unique pieces of outerwear from brands like COMME des GARÇONS HOMME PLUS, Rick Owens, Moncler, Issey Miyake, and Stella McCartney.

Atelier GENTLE MONSTER TEGA 01 SUNGLASSES
Check current price

Take your professional wear up a notch with jackets and trousers from Bottega, Alexander Wang, or patron saint of the cool guy, Thom Browne.

Undeniably, fashion addicts and the artistic set are Atelier’s immediate audience. But don’t shy away from this shop if you’re simply curious. Their chic and industrial locations are a visual experience. Moreover, their staff, though posh, is incredibly helpful and unstuffy. 

Conclusion

Each of these New York staples has fun and memorable on-site experiences, and most of them have easy online shopping.

Casually hip guys can peruse bomber jackets and jeans over at Brooklyn Circus, while office workers looking to up their game could customize a suit at Freemans Sporting. Meanwhile, troves like 10 ft. Single are built for treasure hunters.

Unsurprisingly, New York has a universe of options when it comes to menswear. 

Clothing and Style menswear store, New York, style advice

Related Posts

Best SLC Menswear Shops
7 Best Men’s Clothing Stores in Salt Lake City
Best Menswear Stores in LA featured
SoCal Style: The 10 Best Menswear Stores in LA
Best Menswear Stores in Chicago - featured
Windy City Style: 7 Best Menswear Stores in Chicago
How to dress well
How to Dress Well: 10 Basic Style Tips for Men in 2023

About Karlton Miko Tyack

Karlton Miko Tyack is a freelance writer covering watches, gear, and style. He was born in LA, studied art history in Boston, and is a lover of rugby, football, and optimism.

Background: Karlton studied art in Boston while working in local galleries. This led to a career in corporate art consulting, hunting down the perfect pieces for specific brand or business.

Transitioning into freelance writing, he moved back to his hometown of Los Angeles, where he managed top accounts with art publisher TASCHEN. His clientele included prominent names in fashion, luxury, and sports.

He then moved to NYC to work as a client liaison at Sotheby’s auction house in New York, where he worked with collectors of fine art, as well as watches, wine, and whiskey.

A lifelong watch enthusiast, Karlton has worked with quality timepieces of all price points and calibers, vintage and contemporary. Tyack’s watch obsession began when he received an Omega Seamaster for his 15th birthday.

Expertise: Through his work in fine art and with Sotheby's auction house, Karlton has developed a deep knowledge of timepieces, whiskey and menswear. He's written for publishers like LA Weekly and Harvard. Here at TMM, Karlton covers watches and men's fashion.

More Articles by This Author

Facebook Instagram LinkedIn

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download). No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Reader Interactions

Comments

    Ask Me Anything Cancel reply

    Got questions? Want to share your opinion? Comment below!

  1. Daniel Hakimi says

    December 21, 2022 at 8:56 am

    You missed No Man Walks Alone, Dover Street Market, Bode, Nepenthes, Aime Leon Dore, Todd Snyder…

    Plus, if you want a good popup to thrift at, Alfargo’s Marketplace iss the best place in the city.

    Reply
    • Brock says

      December 21, 2022 at 10:56 am

      Thanks for the additions! I’ll add these when the article is updated. The Todd Snyder store is a fun stop, even just to browse.

      Reply

Primary Sidebar

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download).

No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Top 5 Favorites for Fall & Winter 2022

  1. Thursday Boots Captain – still the best Goodyear-welted boot under $200 (full review here) 🥾
  2. Matte for Men SPF Lotion – because you should be using moisturizer with SPF
  3. Darn Tough Wool Socks – possibly the best boot socks you can buy 🧦
  4. Hamilton Khaki Mechanical – perfect everyday mechanical watch under $500 (Amazon/Jomashop)
  5. Flint & Tinder Waxed Jacket – great fit, perfect weight for fall 👍🏼

Trending Articles

Men over 40 style

How to Dress Well In Your 40s and 50s (and Beyond)

Fashion brands for short men

Where to Buy Clothes for Short Men (2022 Guide)

Seiko 5 SNK805

31 Great Watches For Small Wrists (Updated for 2023)

Best Business Casual Shoes for Men

Top 8 Best Business Casual Shoes for Men (2023 Guide)

Business casual outfits

The Complete Guide to Business Casual Style for Men

Topics

  • Clothing & Style
  • Outfit Ideas
  • Fitness
  • Product Reviews
  • Dating & Confidence
  • Grooming
  • Men of Modest Height
  • Income Reports

Footer

The Modest Man logo

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Home • Blog • Resources • Contact • Advertise

 

Privacy Policy & Affiliate Disclosure • Terms & Conditions

 

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

 

Copyright © 2023 The Modest Man (Registered Trademark)