• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Modest Man

  • .
  • Topics
    • Fashion
    • Shoes
    • Accessories
    • EDC
    • Hairstyles
    • Cologne
    • See All
  • Reviews
  • Outfit Ideas
  • About
    • Start Here
    • Contact
Home / Blog / Product Reviews

Taft Review: The Opposite of Minimal Shoes

Published on December 15, 2021 by David Komisarchik · Product Reviews, Shoes May contain affiliate links (what's this?)

In this review, I’ll share my thoughts on whether Taft’s hand-made leather dress shoes, boots and sneakers live up to their hype.

Table of Contents

  • Quick Take
  • About Taft
  • Crafting Taft Shoes
  • The Taft Shoes and Boots I’ve Tried
  • Taft Dress Shoes
  • Taft Loafers
  • Taft Boots
  • Taft Sneakers
  • Taft vs. Thursdays
  • Pros and Cons
  • Questions About Taft
  • Are Taft Shoes for You?
Taft Brand Review

If you’re interested in men’s style, you’ve probably heard of Taft. Maybe you’ve scrolled past a few Taft posts on Instagram or saw their ads come up on your Facebook feed. If you have, you might be  wondering if footwear with such unique designs are right for you. 

When it comes down to brass tacks, you have a decision to make between dress shoes with classic, “safe” designs and a pair that stands out.

Note: This is not a sponsored review. Taft hasn’t paid me to write this review and I am under no obligation to publish it. I’m creating this review as someone who has purchased multiple pairs of Taft shoes on his own.

Okay, let’s dive right in…

Quick Take

Short on time? These are my overall thoughts on the shoes and boots:

Taft does unique shoes, boots, loafers, and sneakers really well. You won’t find anything like them from any other shoe brand. If you do find footwear that looks similar, don’t be fooled – Taft knock-offs usually lack craftsmanship and quality.

Taft footwear
Source: Taft Clothing

Taft shoes give you the premium feel of a $500+ shoe with a totally reimagined look at a fraction of the price. This business model is possible because they are a direct-to-consumer brand.

While most of Taft’s models have little or no break-in period, one gripe I have is that their sizing can be a bit tricky. If you’re a half size, or have a foot that is more narrow / wide than average, it will likely take some trial and error to find a size that will fit you perfectly.

Luckily, if you do have issues with sizing Taft’s customer service is speedy in helping with exchanges.

David Wearing Taft Russel Loafers

Overall, I’m personally a fan of Taft’s stand-out, attention-grabbing shoes. If you’re looking for a pair of “loud” shoes to mix up your options, I say get a pair of Tafts.

About Taft

Kory and Mallory Stevens started Taft, in 2013 out of their tiny apartment in Provo, UT. Taft initially started as a sock brand.

Kory and Mallory Stevens
Source: Taft Clothing

In the process of building out their social media and marketing to grow the sock business, they would buy all kinds of dress shoes as props to model with the socks.

As the brand continued to grow through social media channels (especially Reddit) they started to get more and more inquiries on where their “model” dress shoes were from and how they could be purchased.

They decided to take the risk and create their own shoes. They learned about the process, sourced manufacturers and materials, and released their first few pairs of shoes and boots. 

David Wearing Taft Prince Shoes

Taft’s mission was to create “boots for the bold,” to allow everyone to express themselves with a bit of vulnerability. 

Now, Taft is surrounded by a community of super fans that seek to continually expand their bold shoe collections.

Crafting Taft Shoes

Taft’s shoes and boots are all handmade by craftsmen in Portugal and Spain. All of their products are stitched from hand-painted or dyed leather sourced in Europe. 

Crafting taft shoes
Source: Taft Clothing

The Taft team sources high-quality leather and materials for all their styles and works closely with their manufacturers to bring their designs to life via his vision. Kory still personally designs Taft’s shoe and boot releases.

The Taft Shoes and Boots I’ve Tried

I purchased my first pair of Taft shoes in 2015. I needed new dress shoes and the unique cross-stitching of the leather upper caught my attention. 

David Wearing Taft Dustin Boots

As a preface, Taft rotates through a lot of designs, leathers, fabrics, etc. They keep popular options available year-round and bring new options in and out of rotation. I’ve tried both popular models and ones that were making their way through the cycle.

For this part of the article, I’ll go through shoes, loafers, boots, and sneakers that I have personally owned. I’ll keep this to styles that they have available at the time I’m writing this article. 

Taft Dress Shoes

Taft dress shoes run true to size. As a reference, I have a standard width foot and am probably a true 9.5 US but can go up to a 10. When purchasing Taft dress shoes I order size 9 US.

Taft dress shoes
Source: Taft Clothing

Taft hasn’t created width options and they generally recommend sizing down in their shoes for the best fit. I’ve found that Taft’s dress shoes can feel a bit more narrow than the average dress shoe.

My recommendation is to know whether you want your shoe to fit snugly, or leave you some extra room if you’re a half size. Focus on personal comfort.

David Wearing Wilson Dress Shoes

I’ve tried their dress shoes in sizes 10 and 9 and ultimately preferred the snug fit. That’s to say that the snug is comfortable and not too tight. If you size down, consider opting for thin socks. 

The Gladiator Shoe

Currently, my favorite pair of Taft dress shoes is The Gladiator Shoe. Gladiator is a good example of what Taft does best: take a familiar style and do something unexpected.

David Wearing Taft Gladiator Shoes

The shoe comes in black or brown and offers a split upper with genuine leather and suede materials as well as unique broguing. It sits on a Goodyear welted sole. 

These shoes were comfortable right out of the box with no real break-in period. If you plan on using them for daily wear (and cover some good mileage), your foot will probably get tired after a full day.

That said, they’ve been great for events where I’m on my feet.

Taft Loafers

It took a few years before Taft released loafers, despite the fact that many of their early adopters were calling for them from the get-go.

Taft Loafers
Source: Taft Clothing

In my experience, Taft loafers fit similarly to their dress shoes. However, the company recommends sizing up on some of the pairs because they can run quite narrow.

I haven’t had an issue keeping the same sizing, but it’s something to keep in mind if you’re caught between sizes and are trying to decide to round up or down. 

Russell Loafers

The Russel Loafers are my favorite loafer style that Taft offers (although The Monaco is a close second).

David Wearing the Taft Russel Loafers

Initially, I tried an older design that sported leather tassels and a print called London, which has since been discontinued and then reiterated.

With several material options ranging from suede to jacquard, The Russell Loafer is another style that they’ve taken and turned on its head .

I‘ve mainly used these loafers as an unexpected style choice for business casual attire in warmer weather. Let me tell you, they definitely make a statement.

Taft Boots

Taft has the largest variety in its designs when it comes to boots. It seems like they do most of their experimenting with materials, leathers, and construction with their lines of boots. 

Taft boots
Source: Taft Clothing

You’ll notice variation in their soles (everything from leather to rubber), the upper materials, and even their height. They’ve created boots for mild weather and boots for wet weather.

Though, I would definitely call the majority of their designs “fashion boots,” as opposed to your “snowy” or “rainy day go-to” boots.

David Wearing Taft Rome Boots

As far as Taft boo sizing goes, the width depends on the model you choose. I usually keep a size 9, but I’ve tried a pair of the Jack Boots in both 9 and 10, and enjoyed having a little extra room for thicker socks.

Taft lasts (the silhouette / construction of the boots) vary between a few lace-up styles and chelsea boots. That’s why sizing and comfort could change between each pair. 

Taft’s vast selection of boots can be overwhelming. If you’re unsure where to start, consider The Jack Boot.

Jack Boots

The Jack Boot was one of Taft’s first designs. As the company has grown and improved, they’ve continued to modify it to keep it current.

David Wearing Taft Jack Boots

I’ve tried a few variations of the Jack Boot (The Eden and The Oxblood) and even with the variation in the sole construction each pair felt like a solid/sturdy boot. 

However, I’ve noticed that the fancier and more intricate the material, the less likely I am to wear them in any sort of inclement weather. The Jack Boot in Eden was not made for rain. You’ll want to keep an eye on the material and fabric of the pair you choose.

Taft Sneakers

Taft sneakers have gone through several design iterations as well. When they first introduced sneakers, they were a bit wider and took on more of an Italian sneaker design shape (like their current model “Sneaker in Woven”). These had a bit more room than their current offerings.

Taft sneakers
Source: Taft Clothing

Their newer designs have gone narrower. The Klay Sneaker is an example of that. Nowadays, Taft sneakers definitely require a size up even if you’re wearing thin or no-show socks. 

At the moment, Taft’s sneaker selection all sport a white rubber sole with most of the variation in the upper materials.

The Klay Sneaker in Red/White

I wished that I’d sized up on these. While a size 9 got me that snug fit, I was hurting by the end of an all-day walk through downtown Denver.

David Wearing Taft Klay Sneakers

Personally, I can let dress shoes slide with a bit of a narrower fit, but I always look for comfort in my sneakers since they get the most use. 

Taft vs. Thursdays

Taft most often gets compared to Thursday Boot Company. While both brands offer sturdy, well-made shoes direct to the consumer, it’s hard to give a definitive answer as to which one is better. Both companies sell great products, but they’re different. 

taft vs thursday
Taft vs. Thursday Boots

Thursday Boots offer a lower price point than most other traditionally styled boots, so you can get a great pair of boots with a little less wallet guilt. They’ve stuck to designs they know work and offer subtle variations. Overall, Thursday sells great, albeit somewhat conservative, boots and shoes.

However, Thursday’s doesn’t give you the wide variety and bold selection that Taft does.Taft gives you options with more personality.

Is one better than the other? No. In my opinion, they meet different needs in your closet. 

Pros and Cons

Here are some simple pros and cons about Taft.

Pros

Here are some positive things about Taft…

Design and Uniqueness: You won’t find boots like these anywhere else. For me, that’s a great thing. They don’t feel mass-produced.

Quality: What you gain in design and uniqueness, you don’t lose in quality. Taft shoes feel like the high-quality options you’d find at other mid-top tier shoe brands.

David Wearing Taft Paris Boots

Price: If we’re comparing similar qualities, you’re going to be spending a lot more somewhere like Allen Edmonds.

Fit: A lot of their styles fit right out of the box with no break-in period. They’re easy to wear.

Community: This might not be something that you’re looking for in a shoe but once you buy your first pair, you’re immediately invited into the Taft community. You’ll notice them on the street and you’ll strike up conversations about which pairs you own and which ones you have your eye on next. 

Cons

No brand is without its cons…

Price: I’m fully aware that $200-$300 for shoes is still quite a bit of money. If you’re just looking for another utilitarian pair of shoes or boots, then these probably aren’t high on your list. 

However, if price is a concern, check their Last Chance/Seconds pages for additional discounts. They also have sales twice a year- in April and again around Black Friday.

Fit: Their sizing can be tough. If you have wide feet, you may struggle with some of their shoes since they skew narrower. Half sizes are also tricky if you’re not sure how you want your Taft shoes to fit. Luckily, their customer service is pretty helpful with exchanges.

Design Over Time: You’ll want to be very sure that you’re not going to have “buyer’s remorse.” Don’t buy Taft shoes on a whim. You should be almost certain that you’ll continue to wear the Taft shoes you bought even after “the honeymoon period.”

Since their designs are more unique, if you’re not careful you may find yourself uninterested in some of the first pairs you bought.

David Wearing Taft Viking Boots

Granted, this could happen with any pair of shoes, but I have found myself reselling some older pairs of Tafts because I got caught up in the initial hype or because Taft released a better version of them.

Overall, I continue to come back to Taft because of the unique design and quality of their shoes, boots, and sneakers. They have been well worth the money spent.

Questions About Taft

Here are some of the most frequently asked questions about Taft:

Where are Taft Shoes Made?

They are handmade in Spain and Portugal. Leather and other materials are sourced from Europe.

Who Owns Taft Boots?

Kory and Mallor Stevens started Taft together and have since expanded their team. Taft is based out of Utah but has since opened storefronts across the country.

How Long Do Taft Shoes Last?

This is highly dependent on how frequently you wear your shoes and on how well you take care of them. Personally, I still have my first pair from 2015.

Does Taft Have Sales?

You can check out their “Last Chance” page for current deals. Otherwise, Taft has biannual sales, usually around Black Friday and another in or around April of each year.

Are Taft Shoes for You?

Taft isn’t for everyone. If your style leans more conservative or traditional then bold Tafts shoes or boots are probably going to be too flashy for you.

Taft’s is for anyone who’s ready to branch out from what they’re used to (and with Taft, you can branch out a little, or a lot). They do a good job of offering both “subtly bold” designs as well as over-the-top designs.

David Wearing Taft Pony Sneakers

If you’re someone who wants traditionally crafted footwear with daring designs made with high-quality materials Taft is probably for you. With their incredibly competitive prices, Taft is definitely worth trying out. 

Questions? Comments? Leave them below!

Product Reviews, Shoes Taft, Taft Shoes

Related Posts

Thursday Boots Legend Chelsea Boots Review
Thursday Boots Legend Chelsea Boots Review: Your New Go-To
Thursday Saint Double Monk Review
Thursday Saint Double Monk Review
Birkenstocks review
Birkenstocks Review After 1.5 Years: They’re Overrated
Ace Marks Wholecut Carlo Oxford Review
Ace Marks Whole-Cut Carlo Oxford Review

About David Komisarchik

David is a menswear and lifestyle content creator focused in exploring bold and personal style. He also educates creators, entrepreneurs and small businesses on how to navigate the influencer marketing industry.

Background: A full-time content creator with a passion for bold men's fashion, David originally started his Instagram account as a creative outlet and departure from his 9-to-5 contracting job.

He eventually moved from his hometown of Denver, CO to New York City in order to be closer to the action. Nowadays, he creates multimedia content around fashion and men's lifestyle, and helps brands with their influencer marketing and content marketing strategy.

Expertise: David has worked with brands like ClassPass, Taft, Nisolo, Samsonite and Abercrombie. He's been a special guest at New York Fashion Week, and he's written for or been featured in publications like Spy, Voyage Denver and Huff Post.

More Articles by This Author

Facebook Instagram LinkedIn

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download). No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Reader Interactions

Ask Me Anything Cancel reply

Got questions? Want to share your opinion? Comment below!

Primary Sidebar

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download).

No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Trending Articles

Men over 40 style

How to Dress Well In Your 40s and 50s (and Beyond)

Fashion brands for short men

Where to Buy Clothes for Short Men (2022 Guide)

Seiko 5 SNK805

31 Great Watches For Small Wrists (Updated for 2023)

Best Business Casual Shoes for Men

Top 8 Best Business Casual Shoes for Men (2023 Guide)

Business casual outfits

The Complete Guide to Business Casual Style for Men

Topics

  • Clothing & Style
  • Outfit Ideas
  • Fitness
  • Product Reviews
  • Dating & Confidence
  • Grooming
  • Men of Modest Height
  • Income Reports

Top 10 Brands

  1. Peter Manning NYC
  2. Uniqlo
  3. Nordstrom
  4. Warby Parker
  5. J. Crew
  6. J. Crew Factory
  7. Amazon
  8. Thursday Boot Co.
  9. Mr. Porter
  10. Banana Republic

New Posts & Videos Every Week

Never miss a new post or video! Sign up for free updates, and I'll send you the "How to Dress Taller" guide for free.

Success! Go check your email...

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime. Powered by ConvertKit
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Footer

The Modest Man logo

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Home • Blog • Resources • Contact • Advertise

 

Privacy Policy & Affiliate Disclosure • Terms & Conditions

 

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

 

Copyright © 2023 The Modest Man (Registered Trademark)