• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Modest Man

  • .
  • Start Here
  • Blog
  • About
  • Free Guide
Home / Clothing and Style / 7 Ways to Prevent and Fix Shirt Sleeves That Are Too Long

7 Ways to Prevent and Fix Shirt Sleeves That Are Too Long

Published on September 2, 2019 by Brock · Clothing and Style

May contain affiliate links (what's this?)

Wondering how to handle shirt sleeves that are too long? You’re in the right place. Here’s how to prevent (and fix) this annoying problem.

Rolling up sleeves
Rolling up your sleeves is one great way to hide excess length, but it’s not your only option…

If you’re a shorter guy, or if you just have short arms for your build, you’ve probably dealt with shirt sleeves that are just too long.

It’s a super frustrating fashion problem that totally ruins your look. Even if everything else is on point, overly long sleeves will make you look like a kid playing dress up.

So how do you deal with this annoying problem?

2 Ways to Prevent Overly Long Sleeves

The best solution is to avoid sleeves that are too long altogether. As the old saying goes:

An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.

For most guys, this means you have two options:

  1. Buy custom shirts
  2. Buy from specialty brands

Let’s look at each option in more details…

#1: Buy Custom Shirts

Going custom is a great option, as there are so many made-to-measure shirt brands these days. You can get a decent quality custom shirt for as low as $50 right now, which is pretty cool!

Flannel layers
This casual button up from Tailor Store is made-to-measure, which is why the sleeve length is perfect.

But going custom has its drawbacks. If you buy from an online made-to-measure brand, which is what most guys do, you’ll have to submit your own measurements.

This is a tricky process that often results in an ill-fitting shirt, especially for first time custom buyers.

ShirtCycle Sample Shirt
Unfortunately, this is a somewhat typical first attempt with a new MTM shirt brand.

It just takes a while to really dial in your fit, and most guys give up too soon, feeling frustrated because they expected the process to be easier (which is what MTM brands always promise).

It also takes a long time, usually 3-6 weeks, to get your shirt made and shipped to your door.

Bottom line: buying custom shirts is a great option for guys who need shorter sleeves, but don’t expect to get a perfectly fitting shirt the first time.

#2: Shop Specialty Brands

These days, shorter guys (who guys with shorter arms) have the option to shop brands like Jimmy Au’s that make clothes specifically for shorter men.

All of their shirts, including casual button ups and dress shirts, have shorter sleeves. You can find a complete list of these brands right here.

Business casual style

They’re perfect for shorter men or anyone who has issues with off the rack sleeve length from most major brands.

Since these are ready-to-wear shirts, you won’t need to go through the custom fitting process or visit a tailor. You can just buy the shirts online and start wearing them within a week.

You can also try brands like Hugh & Crye that use proprietary sizing systems based on height and weight.

Hugh and Crye button-down collar Teal, white check brushed twill
Check out our Hugh & Crye review for more info.

More and more brands are trying to solve these fit problems using technology and smarter sizing systems, and these brands are definitely worth a shot.

But what about all of those shirts you already own?

5 Ways to Fix Sleeves That Are Too Long

You probably already have a few shirts in your closet that look great, other than the sleeves being too long.

Here’s how to deal with these shirts:

#1: Wear Another Layer

This works best in cooler seasons, but it can be done in spring and summer as well.

Just wear a jacket or sweater over your dress shirt or button down. This extra layer will hide the excess length of your sleeves.

Smart casual layers
Are my shirt sleeves too long? No one will ever know 😉

I know, it’s an obvious solution, and you probably already have a few shirts that you only wear under sweaters.

But this trick is clutch during fall and winter, so I wanted to mention it!

If you need help with sweaters, check out this guide to sweaters for shorter men.

#2: Roll Up Your Sleeves

With increasingly casual workplaces, most business casual professionals can get away with rolling up their sleeves everyday.

It’s a casual, masculine look that totally hides any excess sleeve length (in a non-obvious way).

J Crew sleeve roll tutorial roll

If your sleeves are nice and slim, you can roll them however you’d like. If your sleeves are a bit baggy, I recommend rolling them above your elbow using the so called J. Crew roll (shown above).

#3: The Faux French Cuff

If your sleeves are really long — like several inches past your wrist — try this trick.

Faux French cuff sleeve roll
The faux “French Cuff” sleeve roll | Source: SMK Style

You simply roll your sleeves once, then button them in reverse (or inverted) to create a French cuff look.

I wouldn’t do this without a jacket, as it’s a somewhat obvious trick.

#4: Try Sleeve Garters

Sleeve garters are an old school accessory that you really don’t see much anymore.

That said, old-timey accessories always seem to come back into style eventually. Just look at the resurgence of suspenders, bow ties and fedoras.

Sleeve garters in Peaky Blinders
Just because Thomas Shelby looks cool wearing sleeve garters doesn’t mean everyone will! | Source: Peaky Blinders

You could definitely set yourself apart with a pair of sleeve garters, if you had the confidence to pull them off.

If you do wear sleeve garters, I recommend avoiding other bold accessories (like a fedora or suspenders), as you could easily slide into Peaky Blinders cosplay territory (great for Halloween but not Wednesday staff meetings).

#5: Get Them Tailored

This is the best way to deal with sleeves that are too long on shirts you already own.

Simply go to a tailor and get the sleeves shortened, and they’ll fit your arms perfectly.

Clothing alterations costs
Tailoring is every stylish man’s secret weapon.

This will cost you anywhere from $10-25 depending on where you live, but it’s totally worth it (and cheaper than buying a new shirt).

For more info about getting your shirts tailored, check out the clothing alterations guide.

Closing Thoughts

When it comes time to buy a new shirt, try to prevent sleeves that are too long by going custom or buying clothes made specifically for shorter men.

For shirts you already own, the best long-term solution is to get them tailored. For a quick fix, try rolling them up or wearing an extra layer.

Got any other tricks up your overly long sleeve? Leave a comment below!

Clothing and Style Filed Under:button up shirts, dress shirts, shirt sleeves, short mens fashion 3 comments

Related Posts

How to roll your sleeves up
7 Ways to Roll Your Shirt Sleeves Up (Visual Guide)
Charcoal plaid suit pattern mixing
Where to Buy Dress Shirts for Short Men [2021 Guide]
Style for short stout men
How to Dress if You’re Short, Stout and Hefty
lululemon shorter length joggers
Where to Buy Joggers for Short Men (Hands-On Review)

About Brock

Founding editor of The Modest Man, Brock is an aspiring minimalist who enjoys working out, spending time with his wife and family, traveling and creating great content. You can follow Brock on Instagram, Facebook and Twitter.

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download). No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Mike says

    September 11, 2019 at 2:18 am

    Great article! I usually opt for the trailor. But often I feel they end up still too long (because I was too scared to take off too much), or they’re too short (which could be more mental, since I’m not used to seeing my wrists peak that far out). And are slightly shorter sleeve lengths still in style? 🤷‍♂️

    Reply
  2. GEGJr says

    September 11, 2019 at 2:51 am

    I only have issues with shirts that are sold by size letter such as L(large), M(medium), etc. When I buy dress shirts I can typically get a shirt in my size which is 16-16.5 neck, 32-33 sleeve length. And with the trend to make shirts in various body styles, like slim and classic fit, the dress shirt is pretty good fit. I have written and called many, many companies, J Crew included, to complain about how they size their shirts and sports coats because their sleeves are typically sized 34-35 or 33-34 for a size 16-16.5 neck both of which tend to be to long for a man 5’7″ to 5’8″. I had purchased dress/casual shirts last fall from J Crew that I really liked and were on sale. They fit great everywhere except the sleeves. Fortunately, I have alteration shop I frequent that will shorten sleeves for $10 a shirt and they do a great job. And since the shirts were on sale I didn’t feel so bad about paying to get them altered. However, I will remind everyone to be careful with getting sleeves altered, anything really, because in the beginning they missed stitching the cuff all the way around the shirt sleeve and I had to take it back after wearing it because I didn’t check it before I left the shop. Lesson learned. I didn’t abandon the alterations shop because she normally does a great job. But I do check and if necessary try on when I pick up now.

    Reply
  3. Mario Benavides says

    September 11, 2019 at 9:48 am

    I pretty much get all my shirt sleeves tailored. The one thing I dislike about it is that the wrist area gets tighter. No problem when wearing the shirt sleeves normally but I can’t roll them up if I want to. I often get short sleeved shirts tailored as well because they’re often too long.

    As an aside, I’m digging the longer hair Brock. You’re definitely rocking the look.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download).

No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Top 5 Favorites for Fall/Winter 2021

  1. Oliver Cabell Chelsea Boot – 3oz suede upper, Italian crepe sole, made in Spain, under $250
  2. Everlane Performance Chino – looks like a chino, feels like a travel pant (comfy but not too tech-y)
  3. Smartwool Light Crew Hiking Socks – not cheap, but some of the best wool socks to wear with boots (at any price)
  4. Seiko SNK809 – the best automatic watch under $150 you can buy (perfect for someone’s first mechanical watch)
  5. Ash & Erie Henley – finally, a long sleeve henley shirt that fits properly on shorter men (and shorter arms)

Most popular posts

The 10 Best Fall Shoes for Men (2021 Guide)

Ready to Wear vs Bespoke

Bespoke vs. Made-to-Measure vs. Off the Rack: What’s the Difference?

Seiko 5 SNK805

25 Great Watches For Small Wrists (Updated for 2021)

Business casual style for men

The Complete Guide to Business Casual Style for Men [2021]

ClipperLever ft

A Beginner’s Guide to Cutting Your Own Hair at Home

Topics

  • Clothing & Style
  • Outfit Ideas
  • Fitness
  • Product Reviews
  • Dating & Confidence
  • Grooming
  • Men of Modest Height
  • Income Reports

Footer

The Modest Man logo

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Home • Blog • Resources • Contact • Advertise

 

Privacy Policy & Affiliate Disclosure • Terms & Conditions

 

Copyright © 2021 The Modest Man (Registered Trademark)