• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Modest Man

  • .
  • Start Here
  • Blog
  • About
  • Outfit Ideas
  • Free Stuff
Home / Blog / Clothing and Style / Accessories

8 Men’s Scarves That Keep You Warm and Stylish

Published on December 14, 2022 by Ian Chandler · Accessories May contain affiliate links (what's this?)

Want to buy a scarf? You have roughly tons of choices. Don’t worry: we hand-picked the best scarves for guys to buy this year.

Table of Contents

  • Quick Take
  • The Best Men’s Scarves
  • What To Look For In a Scarf
  • Should You Even Wear a Scarf?
  • FAQs About Men’s Scarves
  • Which Scarf is Right for You? 
Best Mens Scarves
Photo by EdZbarzhyvetsky / Depositphotos.com

The humble scarf is one of the more underrated fall/winter garments. Even if you’ve invested in a great winter coat, you can still get a lot of mileage from the right scarf.

A scarf can tie an outfit together, add a splash of color, or provide contrast with a unique design.

And, of course, scarves are extremely practical, adding insulation and providing extra protection against the chilly bite of winter.

What’s more, you can wear a scarf with just about any fall or winter (or even spring) outfit. You can also change the type of scarf knot to transform an entire look, which further proves just how versatile scarves are.

Quick Take

Here are our top three recommendations from the list:

Our Pick
Buck Mason Pine Donegal Scarf
Buck Mason Pine Donegal Scarf
$145

Buck Mason's Pine Donegal Scarf, a richly hued garment made from a blend of merino wool, nylon, and alpaca. If you’re after a mid-weight scarf that looks incredible, then this might be for you.

Buy Now
Budget Pick
Tentree Cotton Ribbed Scarf Meteorite Black
Tentree Cotton Ribbed Scarf Meteorite Black
$68

Tentree Cotton Ribbed Scarf is a minimal option that keeps things simple. It’s one of the lighter scarves, so you can wear it in early fall and spring without your neck overheating.

Buy Now
Upgrade Pick
Burberry Giant Icon Check Cashmere Scarf
Burberry Giant Icon Check Cashmere Scarf
$520

The Giant Icon Check is one of the most recognizable scarves ever. It is quintessentially British with its timeless tartan pattern and 100% cashmere construction.

Buy Now

Read on for more info and the complete list…

The Best Men’s Scarves

Now that you know your scarf preferences, you can get to the exciting part! We’ve made it easy by handpicking 8 of the best men’s scarves out there right now, and there’s something for everyone here.

Here they are (sorted in alphabetical order for simplicity):

Barbour Wool & Cashmere Tartan Scarf

Barbour is most famous for its field jackets, but this British heritage brand also makes a mean scarf.

Barbour Cashmere Tartan Scarf
Barbour Schal Wolle Kaschmir Tartan Scarf

This classic scarf is one of Barbour’s best. It’s made from a premium blend of merino wool and cashmere and features a traditional tartan pattern. It’s an unmistakably British look that pairs nicely with plenty of cold weather fits.

It’s hard to go wrong with any of the 8 colorways, but if you want the trademark Barbour look, then you’ll probably want to opt for the classic or dress tartan.

Buck Mason Pine Donegal Scarf

While Buck Mason isn’t a heritage brand, you could easily mistake it for one thanks to its modern-meets-vintage approach to design.

Buck Mason Pine Donegal Scarf
Buck Mason Pine Donegal Scarf

That’s especially true for its Pine Donegal Scarf, a richly hued garment made from a blend of merino wool, nylon, and alpaca. You get the classic Donegal flecks with added shape retention from the nylon and warmth from the alpaca wool.

It’s a seriously handsome scarf, though it’s priced quite high for a scarf that’s 30% nylon. If you’re after a mid-weight scarf that looks incredible (and you don’t mind synthetics), then this might be for you.

Burberry Giant Icon Check Cashmere Scarf

This legendary piece from Burberry is one of the most recognizable scarves ever. Despite the eye-watering price tag, it earns a spot on this list for its unmatched status.

The Giant Icon Check is quintessentially British with its timeless tartan pattern and 100% cashmere construction. It’s available in 25 colors, so you can easily find one that works with your wardrobe.

Burberry Giant Icon Check Cashmere Scarf
Burberry Giant Icon Check Cashmere Scarf

The Archive Beige color is by far the most classic (and arguably the most versatile).

You’ll have to fork over $520 for it, but if you’re after a buy-it-for-life scarf that you can wear with anything, it might be the right investment to make (but, understandably, for the vast majority of guys, that’s a ludicrous price for a scarf).

Everlane ReCashmere® Scarf

If sustainability is a key concern for you, then you’ll appreciate this scarf from Everlane.

Everlane ReCashmere Scarf
Everlane The Cashmere Scarf

The ReCashmere® Scarf foregoes virgin materials in favor of a blend of 96% recycled cashmere and 4% recycled sheep’s wool. You can choose from 5 solid colors and 2 striped patterns, all of which share the same simple design.

It’s rare to find a scarf with completely recycled construction, so that’s a big plus. And with its clean edges and lack of tassels, the ReCashmere® is also one of the most minimal scarves on this list, which will be an extra advantage for some.

NAADAM Essential Ribbed Cashmere Scarf

At first glance, this cashmere scarf from NAADAM seems like any other cashmere scarf, but there’s a fascinating story behind the garment’s rather plain appearance.

The Essential Ribbed Cashmere Scarf is crafted from 100% Mongolian cashmere, which NAADAM sources by working directly with local herders.

Naadam signature ribbed cashmere scarf
NAADAM Essential Ribbed Cashmere Scarf

In keeping with nomadic traditions, the wool is hand-combed instead of sheared, resulting in longer, softer fibers for a more comfortable scarf.

The scarf itself is simple and elegant, ready to be thrown on top of your favorite cold-weather outfit. It’s a slightly more premium option, but it’s one to consider if you’re after an unparalleled balance of warmth and comfort.

Opera Campi Sciarpa Zero

Italian brand Opera Campi is all about hemp. As it turns out, this underused fiber is great for scarves.

The Sciarpa Zero scarf is part of the brand’s Zero line, which uses 100% pure hemp with zero dyes, treatments, or processes.

Opera Campi Sciarpa Zero Scarf
Opera Campi Sciarpa Zero Scarf

Its thick and heavy construction offers more than enough warmth, and the undyed natural hue works well with a wide range of outfits.

For a small fee, you can even get the scarf made-to-measure to your ideal length and width. Overall, it’s great for anyone after a natural scarf that provides the insulating benefits of wool without any scratchiness.

Paul Smith Mixed-Stripe And Check Wool Scarf

Paul Smith is another stalwart designer brand that’s famous for its scarves.

While there are many great Paul Smith scarves, this Mixed-Stripe And Check Wool Scarf stands out thanks to its subtle yet rich color palette.

Paul Smith Mixed Stripe And Check Wool Scarf
Paul Smith Mixed-Stripe And Check Wool Scarf

Made from 100% lambswool in England, this scarf features a muted check gradient pattern that’s somehow both vibrant and understated.

It’s fantastic for adding a bit of extra color to a neutral outfit, but it’s also low-key enough to be an everyday scarf.

Tentree Cotton Ribbed Scarf

Tentree is another company known for its range of sustainable clothing, so it’s no surprise to see this organic cotton scarf in its catalog.

Tentree Cotton Ribbed Scarf
Tentree Cotton Ribbed Scarf

The Cotton Ribbed Scarf is another minimal option that keeps things simple — its full cardigan knit is only interrupted by a small cork trim on the end.

It’s one of the lighter scarves on this list, so you can wear it in early fall and spring without your neck overheating.

What To Look For In a Scarf

Material and size are the biggest considerations when it comes to scarves. Both of these aspects will impact the overall comfort level of a scarf.

Scarf Materials

When choosing a scarf material, think about how much warmth you’ll need. Generally, woolen scarves run hotter, while scarves made from other fibers tend to provide less warmth.

More specifically, natural fibers tend to be more insulating than synthetic ones. (Of course, there are exceptions to these rules.)

Here’s a quick look at the most common scarf materials:

Wool

By far the most popular scarf material, wool is lauded for its warmth.

Cashmere in particular is one of the most widely used materials because it provides both warmth and comfort. It’s also usually much softer than sheep’s wool, which can be scratchy.

Cotton

This is a decent material that makes for a balanced scarf. Plus, cotton (even organic cotton) tends to be cheaper than cashmere.

It’s a good choice if you want a multi-season scarf, but it doesn’t provide the most warmth (especially when wet or damp), or the most comfort.

Polyester/Acrylic

These materials are much cheaper than natural fibers, so the quality tends to suffer. They also don’t provide that much warmth.

Unless you’re on a really tight budget, it’s best to avoid polyester scarves.

Other Materials

Linen, silk, hemp, and bamboo are some other natural fibers commonly used for scarves.

These vary in warmth and softness, so it’s worth doing a bit of research if you end up going with one of them.

Scarf Sizing

Next, there’s size. Even though scarves are pretty basic, you’ll need to choose width and length measurements that suit you.

Most scarves are around 60” to 70” long and 6” to 10” wide, but you can find many scarves with measurements outside of these parameters. In addition, there are oversized scarves, which are usually both longer and wider.

You should also consider knot style when choosing a length. If you favor intricate knots, then you’ll want to have enough length.

On the other hand, if you’re of more modest stature and prefer a simple drape, you might need a shorter scarf.

Finally, you can always fold a scarf in half if it’s too wide, but this may create unwanted bulk that makes some knots more difficult.

Should You Even Wear a Scarf?

Anymore, the scarf is widely considered a staple men’s wardrobe item, but there are still some guys who consider scarves to be too feminine.

There’s nothing inherently masculine or feminine about scarves — it’s just slightly more common for women to wear them. However, that doesn’t make scarves any less “manly” than t-shirts (which women also wear, by the way).

That said, scarves won’t suit everyone’s style. Even though they go well with all kinds of outfits, scarves have a distinct look that you may not want to go for all the time.

Still, it’s worth having at least one good scarf in your closet. (Though you’ll probably end up with a few after you realize how amazing scarves are.)

FAQs About Men’s Scarves

Here are answers to some of the most commonly asked questions about scarves for men:

Are Men’s Scarves in Style in 2023?

Absolutely! If anything, scarves are more in style than ever before.

What Is a Good Length for a Man’s Scarf?

60” to 70” is standard length, so that’s a good range to look for (unless you’re exceptionally short or tall).

What Is a Man’s Scarf Called?

There’s no surprise answer here — a man’s scarf is just a scarf. (Neckerchiefs, ascots, and pocket squares are all separate garments).

What Are the Best Scarves?

The answer to this question totally depends on what you need. Though cashmere scarves are often considered the most high-end, there’s no universal consensus on what the “best” scarves are.

Which Scarf is Right for You? 

A good scarf is an excellent addition to any man’s wardrobe, so if you don’t have one already, you should really consider picking one up.

For the best experience, stick to high-quality natural materials like wool or cotton and avoid itchy, harmful synthetics.

And don’t forget to experiment with different scarf knots! You’ll quickly find out how much variation you can get out of the same scarf.

Questions? Comments? Leave them below!

Accessories Buying Guides, scarf

Related Posts

Best Gold Necklaces for Men
Top 13 Best Gold Necklaces for Men (2023 Guide)
Harber London desk mat
3 Functional and High-Quality Desk Mats for Your Home Office
Best Leather Watch Straps for Men’s Watches - featured
Top 16 Best Leather Watch Straps for Men
Best NATO Straps for Watches
Top 10 Best NATO Straps for Watches [2022 Guide]

About Ian Chandler

Ian Chandler is a freelance writer with a penchant for men's hair and style (and hairstyle). He enjoys spending time with his girlfriend, reading, playing music, and overthinking.

Background: Ian Chandler is a copywriter and writing instructor from Kent, OH. He’s been writing professionally for 9 years and specializes in business, marketing, and men’s fashion. He holds a Bachelor of Arts in English from Kent State University.

Expertise: Ian is the cofounder of Writing Launch, an online training platform for freelance writers. As Head Instructor, he has helped thousands of new freelancers from around the world find success and grow their careers.

Ian's book The No B.S. Guide to Freelance Writing was published in 2016. His work can be found in The Penny Hoarder, SitePoint, Social Media Explorer and more.

More Articles by This Author

Instagram LinkedIn

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download). No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Reader Interactions

Ask Me Anything Cancel reply

Got questions? Want to share your opinion? Comment below!

Primary Sidebar

Join the Club

Never miss a post, plus grab this free guide (instant download).

No spam. Ever.

Subscribe Now

Top 5 Favorites for Fall & Winter 2022

  1. Thursday Boots Captain – still the best Goodyear-welted boot under $200 (full review here) 🥾
  2. Matte for Men SPF Lotion – because you should be using moisturizer with SPF
  3. Darn Tough Wool Socks – possibly the best boot socks you can buy 🧦
  4. Hamilton Khaki Mechanical – perfect everyday mechanical watch under $500 (Amazon/Jomashop)
  5. Flint & Tinder Waxed Jacket – great fit, perfect weight for fall 👍🏼

Trending Articles

Men over 40 style

How to Dress Well In Your 40s and 50s (and Beyond)

Fashion brands for short men

Where to Buy Clothes for Short Men (2022 Guide)

Seiko 5 SNK805

31 Great Watches For Small Wrists (Updated for 2023)

Best Business Casual Shoes for Men

Top 8 Best Business Casual Shoes for Men (2023 Guide)

Business casual outfits

The Complete Guide to Business Casual Style for Men

Topics

  • Clothing & Style
  • Outfit Ideas
  • Fitness
  • Product Reviews
  • Dating & Confidence
  • Grooming
  • Men of Modest Height
  • Income Reports

Footer

The Modest Man logo

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Home • Blog • Resources • Contact • Advertise

 

Privacy Policy & Affiliate Disclosure • Terms & Conditions

 

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

 

Copyright © 2023 The Modest Man (Registered Trademark)